As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read disclosure policy.
The vegetarian main is usually the dish that gets planned last, so I start there. These are my 15 vegetarian Thanksgiving main dishes, grouped into roasts, stuffed vegetables, baked pastas and pies. Six are fully vegan, and I’ve noted which ones you can make ahead.
How I pick a vegetarian Thanksgiving main
I developed my mushroom Wellington after years of bringing awkward side-dish plates to Thanksgiving. It’s the centerpiece in my own Thanksgiving menus now, and it’s the first recipe on this list.
A Thanksgiving main has to hold the middle of the plate next to stuffing, mashed potatoes and gravy. So every recipe here slices or scoops cleanly, carries savory depth, and is something I’d serve to a full table.
If you want the most hands-off Thursday, start with the ones marked make-ahead. If you’re feeding a crowd, the baked pastas and casseroles stretch the furthest.
These are the mains you carry to the table whole and slice there.
5 from 34 votes
Make-Ahead Mushroom Wellington with Portobellos
Portobello caps, a lentil-mushroom filling and a white bean spread, wrapped in puff pastry. Vegan. The spread and filling can be made up to two days ahead, so Thursday is just assembly and baking.
Chickpea seitan, steamed, basted with garlic butter and wrapped in rice paper for a crispy skin. Vegan. Steam it the day before and brown it to serve. Make it as a loaf, or triple it for a whole turkey shape.
A whole head of cauliflower roasted under a gochujang, soy and tahini sauce. Vegan. It’s spicy, so taste the sauce first and soften it with more tahini if you need to.
Chickpea seitan, steamed and then roasted under a maple-mustard glaze. Vegan. It’s our Easter and Christmas main, and it fits a Thanksgiving table too.
Each person gets their own, which makes these easy to plate and easy to scale.
5 from 44 votes
Vegetarian Stuffed Acorn Squash with Quinoa and Crispy Mushrooms
Roasted acorn squash halves filled with quinoa, walnuts, cranberries and peas, topped with garlicky crispy mushrooms. Vegan and gluten-free. Make the filling ahead and roast the squash on the day.
Red lentils, browned mushrooms and a splash of brandy under a thick layer of buttery mashed potatoes, broiled until the ridges crisp. The recipe notes cover a vegan version.
I'm the recipe developer, photographer and brain behind Urban Farmie. I’m a lifelong vegetarian. I’ve lived, worked, and traveled to 60+ countries and bring you authentic, vegetarian recipes from all those travels!